Rarity Bay Homes for Sale

Rarity Bay Homes for Sale

Welcome to Rarity Bay, an enchanting lakeside community nestled in the heart of Vonore, Tennessee. This picturesque subdivision offers a unique blend of natural beauty, luxurious living, and a vibrant community spirit. With its stunning views of Tellico Lake and the majestic backdrop of the Great Smoky Mountains, Rarity Bay is a haven for those seeking a serene yet active lifestyle.

Rarity Bay boasts a diverse selection of homes for sale, catering to a wide range of tastes and preferences. Whether you’re in search of a charming cottage, a spacious family home, or a modern luxury residence, you’ll find it here. Many properties feature exquisite architectural designs, open floor plans, and outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining or simply soaking in the breathtaking surroundings. Imagine waking up to the sound of birds chirping and the gentle lapping of water at your doorstep!

The community is not just about beautiful homes; it also offers an array of amenities to enhance your living experience. Residents can enjoy access to a private marina, a championship golf course, and a clubhouse that hosts various social events throughout the year. With walking trails, parks, and recreational activities at your fingertips, there’s always something to do in Rarity Bay.

If you’re looking for a place that combines luxury living with a close-knit community atmosphere, Rarity Bay is the perfect choice. Explore the homes for sale today and discover your dream home in this idyllic Tennessee paradise!

Newest Rarity Bay Homes for Sale

$599,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1353692 MLS
Rarely does a home in Rarity Bay offer this combination of true one-level living, a supersized 0.43-acre lot, incredible views, and a $599,000 price point. Situated in a quiet, tucked-away setting, this beautifully landscaped and exceptionally well-maintained home features all of its square footage on one level--an increasingly hard-to-find feature within the community. The oversized side yard creates a wonderful sense of openness and privacy, while golf course views surround the property and beautiful mountain views provide the perfect backdrop. Inside, the expansive open floor plan is filled with natural light, with views seemingly everywhere you look. The main living areas feature true hardwood floors, 11-foot ceilings, and a stacked-stone fireplace. The kitchen offers granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and an open design that flows seamlessly into the living and dining areas. The spacious primary suite features cathedral ceilings, a large walk-in closet, dual vanities, a walk-in shower, and separate soaking tub. Outside, a two-tiered patio provides plenty of space to relax, entertain, and enjoy the peaceful setting, beautiful landscaping, golf course, and mountain views. Additional highlights include an oversized 24' x 28' two-car garage with extra-tall ceilings, a large laundry room, encapsulated crawl space with dehumidifier, reverse osmosis system, water softener, HVAC approximately six years old, and a water heater installed in 2023.

240 Goldcrest Drive, Vonore
$1,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1350354 MLS
Exquisite Custom Luxury Home with Breathtaking Mountain & Lake Views in Rarity Bay Experience refined luxury and timeless elegance in this exceptional custom-built residence, perfectly situated within the prestigious gated community of Rarity Bay. Impeccably landscaped grounds set the stage for a home defined by superior craftsmanship, sophisticated finishes, and sweeping views of the golf course, mountains, and Tellico Lake. Inside, rich hardwood floors, soaring ceilings, extensive custom cabinetry, and intricate crown molding create an atmosphere of warmth and elegance. Expansive windows and transoms flood the home with natural light, accentuating the open floor plan and showcasing the home's exceptional architectural details. Designed to inspire both everyday living and effortless entertaining, the gourmet kitchen features a generous center island, granite countertops, custom cabinetry, a spacious pantry, and an impressive suite of premium appliances, including a Sub-Zero refrigerator, KitchenAid double ovens, a Scotsman ice maker, dual dishwasher drawers, and a trash compactor. The adjoining breakfast nook offers a charming setting for casual meals, while the formal dining room provides an elegant space for hosting family and friends. The main-level primary suite is a private retreat, complete with soaring ceilings, transom windows, and tranquil mountain and lake views. Dual custom walk-in closets provide exceptional storage, while the spa-inspired ensuite bath offers a luxurious escape. A beautifully appointed powder room completes the main level. One of the home's most captivating spaces is the expansive screened porch, where breathtaking mountain and lake vistas create the perfect setting for morning coffee, evening cocktails, or simply enjoying the serenity of East Tennessee. An adjoining all-season sunroom, surrounded by walls of windows, extends the living space year-round and frames the spectacular scenery from every angle. The lower level is thoughtfully designed to accommodate family and guests with comfort and privacy with access from an elevator or staircase. The second bedroom features a private ensuite bath and walk-in closet, while the third and fourth bedrooms each include walk-in closets and share a well-appointed Jack-and-Jill bath. A versatile flex room offers endless possibilities as a home office, media room, fitness space, or hobby room. Generous storage areas and a dedicated workshop space further enhance the home's functionality. Additional features include a hard-coat stucco and brick exterior, a 2.5-car garage, central vacuum system, three HVAC units, and a gas water heater. For those seeking additional privacy or future possibilities, the adjoining lot below the home is available for separate purchase--a rare opportunity within Rarity Bay. Combining exceptional craftsmanship, luxurious finishes, expansive living spaces, and breathtaking views of the golf course, mountains, and Tellico Lake, this extraordinary residence offers an unparalleled lifestyle in one of East Tennessee's most sought-after waterfront communities. Full Golf membership valued at $30,000 available for transfer. $15,000 social initiation fee due to Rarity Bay Country Club at closing.

117 Black Hawk Drive, Vonore
$1,499,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1348413 MLS
Magnificent upscale custom built estate with stack stone and hard coated stucco. Located in the lake and golf community of Rarity Bay. This 5,676 sq. ft. home boasts ¾'' solid wood and Italian Marble flooring, heavy solid wood Pella doors and windows, large Oak crown moldings with extensive solid wood millwork and oak door and window trim details throughout. This custom home has exquisite stack stone fireplaces, private balconies, and spectacular views of the golf course and lake. The main level features a grand Italian marble foyer opening to a formal living room, a formal dining room, a Butler Pantry with a Thermador Warming Drawer. The main level also has an elegant powder room, a double sided stack stone fireplace facing both the gourmet kitchen and an extensive family room.The main level also has an office with custom shelving and cabinetry and a spectacular view of the golf course and lake. The chef's kitchen includes an oversized island, elegant granite, Custom Alderwood cabinets,high end appliances and a large eat-in breakfast area with panoramic views of the golf course and lake. There are two balconies with spectacular views, one balcony is completely screened with a ''Somfy'' motorized shade, and outdoor stereo speakers. On the upper level is a spacious master suite with a balcony that has a 3rd story panoramic view. The master has two large separate ''His and Hers'' walk-in closets with built-in cabinets, a coffee bar with a sink and custom cabinetry, a large master bathroom with marble top vanities, spa jetted tub and large shower. Connected to her closet is a large vanity dressing room with custom cabinets. The top level also has two large additional bedrooms with ensuite bathrooms and walk-in closets. The Lower level offers a Media Room, an extensive recreation room and sitting area, full bathroom, fireplace, a half kitchen with sink, refrigerator and custom cabinets, along with a walk-out patio area. Also in the lower level is a large private bedroom with a walk -in closet, with a separate walk out patio area. In addition this floor has a beautiful Tuscan style wine cellar with iron doors, stack stone wall and seated lounge area, two separate wine coolers,a large built-in butcher block counter,and custom built-in wine racks that hold over 1,500 bottles. In the same level there's a spacious fitness room. This elegant Estate is a designer dream for creating a sophisticate lifestyle. This beautiful home is equipped with a ''GENERAC'' Power System Generator and a built in stereo system with ceiling speakers throughout. Rarity Bay is a 24/7 manned gated community that offers an active adult living lifestyle with a fully staffed clubhouse, pro shop, restaurant and bar, golf course, pool, tennis courts, workout center, pool, dog park and boat slips.For this property membership is optional.

859 Rarity Bay Pkwy, Vonore
$739,400
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1348154 MLS
Luxury living awaits in the prestigious gated community of Rarity Bay! This beautifully updated home offers an exceptional blend of elegance, comfort, and thoughtful design. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, stainless steel appliances, double ovens, a gas cooktop, pull-out shelving, and an instant hot water faucet. The spacious main-level primary suite provides comfort and convenience, while the open-concept living area showcases custom built-ins, a gas fireplace, and abundant natural light through windows. Step outside to enjoy the screened porch with a power awning, Trex decking, and travertine patio overlooking beautifully landscaped surroundings with an irrigation system--perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The finished walkout lower level offers a generous family room, three additional bedrooms, a full bath with a newly remodeled walk-in shower, a safe room, plus ample storage. Recent upgrades include new interior and exterior paint, new flooring throughout, new windows, solid-core interior doors, plantation shutters, a new refrigerator (2025), new upstairs HVAC, epoxy garage flooring, a refreshed driveway, and a professionally cleaned roof (2025). Custom office built-ins, fireplace cabinetry, and numerous premium finishes complete this move-in-ready home. Enjoy the unmatched Rarity Bay lifestyle with a country club, championship golf, pickleball, tennis, fitness center, lake access, dining, and more.

137 Heron Court, Vonore
$339,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1348090 MLS
This ground-floor, 3-bedroom end-unit condo in the gated community of Rarity Bay offers plenty of natural light thanks to the abundance of windows throughout the living and kitchen areas. Recent updates include brand-new kitchen appliances, a new HVAC system, fresh interior paint, new ceiling light fixtures with dimmers, brand-new carpet, new toilets, and a dedicated drinking water purification system in the kitchen. The condo also features $18,000 in newly replaced windows and sliders, including 13 windows and both sliding doors. The end-unit location provides additional windows and privacy, while the back patio overlooks the golf course. The living room features hardwood floors, and all square footage is conveniently located on one level with a one-car garage included. Located within walking distance to the community pool, fitness center, clubhouse dining, and golf course, with boat slips nearby for easy access to Tellico Lake. Furniture is negotiable.

555 Rarity Bay Pkwy Unit 101, Vonore
$1,450,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1347997 MLS
Panoramic Tellico Lake and the Smoky Mountains views! This spacious 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath home is a true East Tennessee retreat, offering a thoughtful floor plan, oversized 3-car garage, and an additional basement golf cart/workshop garage. The golf cart also conveys with the property, making it easy to enjoy the community and its many amenities. A large foyer welcomes you into the living room, featuring hardwood floors, custom built-ins surrounding the fireplace, a wet bar with beverage center and sink, and expansive windows that frame the incredible views. A gourmet kitchen offers warm wood cabinetry, granite countertops, dual sinks, a gas cooktop, built-in oven and microwave, 2 walk-in pantries, and a spacious dining area. The large composite deck is a highlight of the home, facing East and perfect for shaded evenings to enjoy your beverage or morning coffee. Both the living room and the primary suite open directly into the enclosed sunroom, which was recently renovated with new flooring. The primary suite is a private retreat filled with natural light, featuring new carpet, a spa-like ensuite with a jetted tub, walk-in tile shower, dual walk-in closets, an attached laundry room, and 2 dedicated office/sitting areas with built-in desks--perfect for working from home or relaxing with a view. A second main-level bedroom with a private ensuite provides comfortable accommodations for guests. The walk-out lower level features 10 foot ceilings, hardwood flooring, a kitchenette, an expansive recreation room, 2 additional bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a versatile 5th bedroom or flex space--ideal for a home gym, studio, media room, or hobby space. Additional highlights include a 2nd laundry room with newer washer and dryer, a workshop with a garage door and built-in cabinetry, extensive unfinished storage, and a covered patio with under-decking. Additional updates and improvements include a newer roof, 2 newer HVAC systems, 2 tankless water heaters, a new front door, epoxy-coated garage floors, a radon mitigation system, and a beautiful paver driveway. As an added bonus, the golf cart conveys with the home! Enjoy Rarity Bay's fabulous amenities, including championship golf, clubhouse dining, fitness center, outdoor pool, tennis and pickleball courts, walking trails, marina access, and more--all within one of East Tennessee's premier gated lake communities. Rarity Bay residents enjoy social gatherings, outings, clubs, and activities. If you've been searching for exceptional views, spacious living, and a thoughtfully updated home designed for everyday comfort and entertaining, this is a property you won't want to miss!

1510 Rarity Bay Pkwy, Vonore
$765,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1343980 MLS
Perched above the street with beautiful golf course views behind and Tellico Lake just across the road, this meticulously maintained home offers an exceptional blend of privacy, quality, and lifestyle. Mature landscaping and timeless architecture create impressive curb appeal, while the home's craftsmanship and pride of ownership are evident throughout. Designed to take full advantage of its setting, the home features inviting outdoor living spaces on both the front and back. Enjoy your morning coffee while catching glimpses of the lake from the front patio, or unwind in the evenings overlooking the golf course. The centerpiece of the home is the all-season sunroom, a bright and versatile space that can be enjoyed year-round. Inside, you'll find hardwood floors, coffered ceilings, and a spacious, thoughtfully designed floor plan. The oversized primary suite serves as a private retreat, complete with two walk-in closets and a generously sized ensuite bath. For golf enthusiasts, a Premier Golf Membership valued at $30,000 is available to transfer, providing access to the Rarity Bay semi-private golf course and unlimited golf privileges. Located within the gated waterfront community of Rarity Bay, residents enjoy an active lifestyle with golf, tennis, pickleball, fitness facilities, swimming pool, onsite dining, walking trails, social clubs, and nearby covered boat slips just a short golf cart ride away. This is East Tennessee lake living at its finest.

310 Pineberry Drive, Vonore
$618,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1342977 MLS
At approximately $172 PER SQUARE FOOT, this is about as close to rock-bottom pricing as you will find in Rarity Bay for a full-size home on a larger, estate-style lot--not a villa. Even better, Country Club membership is OPTIONAL, giving owners the flexibility to enjoy one of Tellico Lake's premier gated communities without mandatory club dues. Annual HOA dues are only $1,212. Located on a quiet, tucked-away section of desirable Sandpiper Drive, the home sits on a large, level corner lot with mature landscaping and excellent curb appeal. The street has minimal traffic and is surrounded by impressive properties, including multi-million-dollar lakefront homes just across the street. Inside, the home features hardwood floors throughout the main living areas, a stacked-stone fireplace, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a spacious screened porch that extends the living space outdoors. The primary suite offers generous room sizes and a large walk-in closet. With a few cosmetic updates, buyers have an excellent opportunity to personalize the home and build equity while remaining well below the cost of constructing a comparable property today. Whether used as a full-time residence or second home, this property offers an increasingly rare combination of size, privacy, flexibility, and value in one of East Tennessee's most desirable gated lake communities.

612 Sandpiper Drive, Vonore
$629,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1338810 MLS
AMAZING VIEWS! Upon entering Rarity Bay you will pass the equestrian center to the 24 hour manned gate. Enjoy beautiful sunrises from you deck along with water and mountain views. Just steps from CC and all the amenities including clubhouse, golf, pickle ball, tennis and pool. Almost all new windows and a brand new lower level HVAC and hot water heater.

204 Kingbird Drive, Vonore
$550,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1338781 MLS
Welcome to this beautiful 'lock-and-leave' home in the prestigious, private golf course community of Rarity Bay. This three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath residence is designed for both comfort and convenience. The main level features a spacious great room, a dedicated study with built-in desk and cabinetry, and a private primary suite. The lower level offers a generous family room, versatile flex space, and two well-appointed guest suites--perfect for hosting family and friends. Nestled among mature trees, the home showcases hardwood and tile flooring throughout, adding warmth and character. Enjoy peaceful outdoor living from two expansive screened porches overlooking a serene, wooded setting. New roof in 2025! More than just a home, this property offers a true lifestyle. Located in sought-after Rarity Bay, residents enjoy private lake access and optional boat slips--ideal for water enthusiasts. The open floor plan is perfect for entertaining, while the cozy fireplace adds charm and elegance. A country club membership is required (one-time fee of $15,000 plus $309/month). A full golf membership--a $30,000 value--may transfer to the buyer at no additional cost, if desired. All landscaping and yard work is done by the HOA. Don't miss this opportunity to enjoy resort-style living in one of East Tennessee's premier communities. Schedule your private showing today. Priced to sell! Copies of restrictions visit www.raritybaycai.com and click resources.

129 Heron Court, Vonore
$1,099,950
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1332400 MLS
Welcome home to incredible panoramic Lake and Mountain views -- enjoyed from nearly every room! This beautiful Brick and stucco basement ranch-style home is located in the highly sought-after gated community of Rarity Bay. The great room features 14-ft ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, and a gas fireplace. The kitchen offers granite counters, stainless appliances, and a spacious pantry. The main level features hardwood floors throughout, including the primary suite with a tile and glass shower with dual vanities and two walk-in closets. A main-level office/study can also serve as a fifth bedroom. Step outside to a large deck that showcases the home's stunning lake and mountain views -- perfect for entertaining or simply relaxing. A sun room provides a peaceful spot to unwind and enjoy the view year-round. The lower level includes three additional bedrooms, a second living area with bar and a full and half bath. The 10 ft ceiling height in the basement allows for a golf hitting bay in the golf cart garage. The golf cart garage and basement bonus room add an additional 500+ square feet of space not counted in the 4464 sq ft of living area. The home has seen many upgrades since 2021 including a new roof, main floor HVAC, gas tank-less hot water heater, redesigned back deck, new basement flooring, and much more. Membership to the Rarity Bay Country Club is OPTIONAL.. Furniture and golf cart are negotiable. Owner/Agent.

206 Wren Court, Vonore
$699,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1325436 MLS
NEW CONSTRUCTION - MAIN LEVEL LIVING! Located in the prestigious, gated community of Rarity Bay. This 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers desirable main level living with an open, light filled floor plan ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Highlights include a stacked-stone fireplace, a spacious primary suite with generous closet space, and a covered rear patio perfect for relaxing or hosting guests. Situated on a desirable level lot, this home provides effortless living paired with exceptional resort-style amenities including a clubhouse, pool, tennis and pickleball courts, golf practice facilities, restaurant, and a private championship golf course with breathtaking mountain and lake views. Golf initiation fee INCLUDED and because of builder's contribution, social initiation fee only $5k. (Buyer responsible for all monthly dues) See documents for more community info and visit raritybayliving.com for more info.

204 Goldcrest Drive, Vonore
Start Your Search